A customer in the US disputes a $120.00 payment. You paid $3.78 in processing fees on it, at Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ card rate. When the dispute opens, Stripe takes $135.00 from your balance: the $120.00 payment and the $15.00 dispute received fee.
- Accept the dispute
- $120.00 + $15.00 + $3.78
- $138.78
- Counter and lose
- $120.00 + $15.00 + $15.00 + $3.78
- $153.78
- Counter and win
- The received fee. The $120.00 and the countered fee come back.
- $15.00
- Win with Smart Disputes
- $15.00 received fee + 30% of $120.00. No countered fee.
- $51.00
Countering manually risks one more $15.00 to save $123.78, so it costs less than accepting whenever your chance of winning is above about 11%. Small disputes change the picture: on a $20.00 payment, the countered fee is a much bigger share of what you could win back. Add goods and staff time to see your real figure.
Disputes also count toward card network monitoring. Stripe lists Visa's excessive VAMP thresholds as a 1.5% ratio and 1,500 disputes and fraud reports a month in most regions (2.2% and 150 in CEMEA), and Mastercard's ECM level as 100 chargebacks and a 1.5% rate. See Stripe's monitoring programs page for how each network counts.
New to the terms? Read what a chargeback and a payment dispute are, and how the Stripe dispute fee works. If a payment was declined rather than disputed, look it up in the Stripe decline codes reference.