approve_with_idThe payment couldn't be authorized

Stripe's approve_with_id decline means the payment couldn't be authorized. Stripe says to try again, then have the customer contact their issuer.

Next step
Retry may work
Hard decline
Not on Stripe's list
Share the reason
Yes

What does approve_with_id mean?

The payment can't be authorized.

What Stripe says to do

Attempt the payment again. If it still can't be processed, the customer needs to contact their card issuer.

What to tell the customer

Try again first. Only ask the customer to call their bank if the retry fails.

Example wording
We couldn't complete your payment. Please try again. If it fails again, your bank can tell you more.

Should you retry approve_with_id?

Yes, once. Stripe's next step is another attempt. It isn't on Stripe's hard decline list, so Stripe Billing retries follow your Smart Retries or custom schedule.

Before any retry, check the charge's outcome.advice_code. try_again_later means the issuer allows a retry, do_not_try_again means don't use the card again for this transaction, and confirm_card_data means some card details need checking.

Where approve_with_id shows up

On a failed PaymentIntent, read last_payment_error.decline_code. On the Charge, the same code is in outcome.reason. Card declines usually come with the error code card_declined and the reason in decline_code.

Get failed payments in Slack

ChargeBell posts a Slack alert when a Stripe payment fails, with the amount, the customer, and Stripe's decline message. Open the payment from the alert to see its decline code, such as approve_with_id, and follow up from there.

Related decline codes

All Stripe decline codes